HEALTH / FITNESS NEWS
July 03, 2012 12:00:00 AM
  Follow @ Twitter

A lab test to screen embryos for inherited risk of breast or ovarian cancer is "feasible" but controversy surrounding this method is unlikely to be stilled, a fertility conference heard on Monday.

European researchers carried out the biggest-ever probe of a procedure to vet in-vitro embryos for gene mutations linked to these notorious cancers.

Their work, presented at a conference in Istanbul, declared the test is a reliable indicator of whether the embryo carries the dangerous BRCA1 and BRCA2 gene variants.

Even so, these genes are by no means a guarantee that cancer will occur, which means a fierce debate over the technique will continue, they said.

The method, called preimplantation genetic diagnosis (PGD), entails taking cells from an IVF embryo while it is still in its earliest stage.

If the embryo does not carry the flawed genes, it is deemed ready for transfer to the uterus, the next step of in-vitro fertilisation (IVF).

PGD has risen to prominence through screening for single-gene diseases such as cystic fibrosis that can doom a child to a life of sickness.

Its use is now being widened to cover the inherited risk for cancer, but this is still at a fledgling stage as doctors debate the pros and cons.

Presented at the annual conference of the European Society of Human Reproduction and Embryology (ESHRE), the new research looked at 717 IVF embryos that were screened for the BRCA1 and BRCA2 variants.

Seventy couples who took part in the study had sought PGD because one partner -- usually the woman -- had a family history of breast or ovarian cancer and they were afraid of handing on the risk to their child.

Of the 717 embryos, 43.1 percent carried a mutation while 40.7 percent were unaffected. The others either had gene abnormalities or analysis of them was inconclusive.

"Our results suggest that PGD for BRCA1 and BRCA2 mutations is feasible, with a good treatment outcome," Willem Verpoest, a professor at the Centre for Reproductive Medicine at Brussels' Free University, said in a press release.

"But controversy will still remain over the ethical acceptability of PGD for a susceptible, yet preventable, condition."

Cancer is a disease with genetic and environmental triggers. Female carriers of either BRCA1 or 2 mutations have a lifetime risk of 60-80 percent of breast cancer.

Carrying just the BRCA1 mutation carries a 30-60 percent risk of ovarian cancer in the course of a lifetime, which falls to five to 20 percent with BRCA2.

Yet many of these cancers occur late in life and there are constantly improving options for preventing and treating them.

This means that someone with the unlucky genes has a very high chance of many years of healthy life -- and a good chance of not developing cancer anyway. In addition, many other genes play a greater or lesser role in cancer.

PGD has also stirred ethical questions beyond the medical field, with critics fearing it could be used as a tool for creating designer babies.

AFP


PREVIOUS STORY
GlaxoSmithKline fined $3bn in US
NEXT STORY
US approves over-the-counter HIV home testing kit

Bookmark and Share
   




FIJI NEWS
Man, 72, gets eight years over rapeA physically disabled 72-year-old man who raped a nine-year-old girl in Levuka late last year has been sentenced to eight years imprisonment.
SPORTS
Focus on form, not results: Fiji U20s coachVodafone Fiji U20s coach Ravinesh Kumar says the OFC Presidentís Cup is a dress rehearsal for the national side ahead of the FIFA U-20 World Cup next year in New Zealand.
TECHNOLOGY
Vodafone Fiji, Tonga telco in allianceVodafone Fiji and Tonga Communications Corporation today signed a strategic partnership alliance that will allow the Tongan company to leverage off the experience of their Fijian counterparts.
LIFESTYLE/FASHION
Tafunaíi ready to fly Fijiís flag highNew crowned Miss World Fiji, Charlene Tafunaíi is ready to do wonders for Fiji in the Miss World Finals in December and is calling for the nationís backing.
ENTERTAINMENT
Logicís debut album Under Pressure out Oct 24After years of hard work in the studio and on the road, Logic has completed his debut album with Under Pressure due to release October 24, with the title track, Under Pressure, is now available.
OFFBEAT
Mercury 'took Princess Diana to gay barQueen singer Freddie Mercury disguised the late Princess Diana as a male model and smuggled her into a notorious gay bar, according to a memoir serialised in Britain's Sunday Times.
NEWS SPORTS INFOTAINMENT SERVICES MOBILE EXTRA HOT TOPICS